Montgomery, Adams & Wyatt, PLC

Montgomery, Adams & Wyatt, PLC

Criminal, Family and Probate Law
View Practice Areas

Can you appeal on the basis of innocence?

After a criminal conviction, a person may be prepared to appeal. In fact, he or she may be ready with new evidence of innocence or new ways to present old evidence. However, the legal system makes it difficult to appeal on the basis of innocence.

What is much more likely to succeed is an appeal on a basis such as technical error. For example, someone could present evidence that police mishandled the case by forcing confessions. Perhaps he or she could argue that the defense attorney was asleep for most of the trial, or that prosecutors concealed evidence. But an argument of innocence is unlikely to get far.

The trial is to determine innocence

One reason that courts rarely consider appeals on the basis of innocence is that the trial should have determined that issue. The idea: It is not the job of appeals judges to retry a defendant. However, it is the job of appeals judges to ensure that the defendant received a fair trial. Thus, if a defendant can show that there was at least one major mistake or mishandling of the case at trial, it could be grounds for a retrial or a reduction in sentence.

That said, there have been cases where something went wrong, perhaps a judge giving the jury erroneous instructions, but it was deemed minor in that it did not influence the outcome of a trial.

What if actual innocence is an issue?

It so happens that many times, lawyers can review trial transcripts and the like to come up with reasonable grounds for appeal, no matter the crime in question. However, there are cases where the judges, lawyers, witnesses and other involved parties seem to have done their due diligence yet the verdict was unjust.

When actual innocence is an issue and there do not seem to be grounds for appeal, it can help to have another lawyer review the case to see if the original attorney missed some grounds for appeal. Failing that, the clemency process can exonerate someone convicted of a crime.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Dedicated Lawyers Serving You | Free Consultation

In need of legal advice? Contact the Little Rock family and criminal law lawyers of Montgomery, Adams & Wyatt, PLC, to get your questions answered. We offer a free consultation. Call us now: 501-377-9568.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy


Montgomery, Adams & Wyatt, PLC
308 East 8th Street
Little Rock, AR 72202

Toll Free: 888-758-4887
Toll Free: 888-758-4887
Phone: 501-377-9568
Phone: 501-377-9568
Fax: 501-375-7943
Little Rock Law Office Map